New Jersey Hunters banner
81 - 99 of 99 Posts
If it was the new world recored he would allow it to be scored and he does not. That there says something.
Mitch had a dispute with the Michigan Big Bucks club and B&C, that's why he never entered it. The following 3 years he killed bucks all 160's and above. I remember reading Outdoor Life magazine, back in the early '70's about him and the bucks he killed, when no one was a "pro staffer" or hung up on scores. Just local guys killing huge bucks
 
All three vouched for it as being real.
he wouldnt let them x ray it... shady

he would have made alot of $$$.... shady


when he goes "hunting" in a burger king, and they go to his house & find severed human heads..maybe we will find out the truth about his world record..
 
It suprises me that everyone doesnt know this story. Every couple of years this pops back up and I usually take the time to read everything again and research it for myself. Im not convinced that its fake, although Im not totally convinced its real either......crazy story and it is likely to stay a crazy story.....
 
Discussion starter · #86 ·
I think we can all agree rampola kills big bucks and is NUTS
 
The guy seems like a wingnut. And no doubt he may have shot some true legit giants, but I don't believe this is one of them. I personally think its fake. He had all the reason in the world to prove everyone wrong but won't. Score or record aside he just sticking to his story and lying low to save face. Read Larry Huffman's article. He has no reason to do anything other than offer his true opinion and if there's anyone who knows giant bucks its him. Rompola is a weirdo who's joke got way outta hand
 
Discussion starter · #88 ·
if we out live him we will find out hopefully ;)
 
he actually cant do anything with it at this point, he has a contract with Milo Hansens layor. Unless someone else shoots a new world record, he cant have it scored or talk about it publicly.
 
Mention his name in the Michigan
That won't be happening anytime soon[hihi][hihi][hihi]

this guy has devorced over deer, has quit jobs to hunt a deer he was after, he is a wack job!
Well that is a sad thing to do over a deer:(


He is no doubt ligit!
Well if he was that will never be known since the rest of the country less those in MI as you say only have doubts and that it seems he will never be able to overcome. Wait! There is a way. just have the buck scored today in front of the P&Y and B&C boards and the truth will come out. With today's media not even those that are trying to blackball him as people say here they are trying to do can stop the truth.

SS!
 
He is no doubt ligit!
By the way how can you say that? Do you have proof he is ligit[confused] Just asking so please do not take this on a attack, just saying since it seems you might know the guy. Like it has been said 2 sides to every story.

SS!
 
he wouldnt let them x ray it... shady
There was also a Michigan Conservation Officer there when he pulled it out of the woods that vouched for it, and some other friends.

Deer and Deer Hunting, a well respected publication, did a story on it and concluded it was real.

If nothing else, a conservation officer, respected publication and three well known, and respected official scorers all put their reputations on the line and vouched for it. They would have alot to lose, wouldn't ya think?

I don't know if it's real but I do know that whenever a guy kills a big buck, hunters always start from the perspective it is fake, photoshopped, poached or something else is wrong. I believe Larry and Craig took advantage of this and ran with it, fed into that hunters-eating-their-own or jealous attack mindset, and this is what we have now.

Think about it, you've seen it with your own two eyes...other people, with reputations to uphold, have seen it, handled it,and say it's real. What does he have to prove? If you think it's fake, the burden of proof lies with you to prove it's fake, not the other way around.

The only reason most hunters are willing to believe this is fake is becuase they didn't kill it, and like always happens when someone else kills a big buck, hunters try to smear them, start rumor campaigns, or try to discredit the accomplishment. This case is no different, except that it's a really big buck.



He is no doubt ligit!
By the way how can you say that? Do you have proof he is ligit
The dozens of other trophy whitetails he has killed pretty much speak to that as proof. The guy consistently kills some monster bucks where other people say there are none. That doesn't mean this one is real, but there sure isn't any evidence it's not real, and not one person who has seen it or touched it is saying it's fake. The only people who are saying it's fake are those who have never even been near the buck.
 
Fair enough but again, do you guys know this guy that you can vouch for his character[confused] Just asking. So what he shot a lot of whitetails, world record is a new ball game.

SS!
 
I was saying he is "legit" as in a legitimate big buck killer. I don't know if this particualr deer is real, but after everything I've read and seen, I have seen no proof it's not real.

Fair enough but again, do you guys know this guy that you can vouch for his character
I'm not vouching for his character. People will have thier own opinions about his character, and those opinions will differ. This isn't about his character, it's about his deer and whether there is any evidence to prove it's not real...evidence, not speculation or allegations.

Again, everyone who has seen or touched it, including a Michigan CO, 3 well respected, official scorers and a magazine writer, have said it's real.

The fake campaign was started by people who have a grudge against him, and picked up and fueled by other jealous, skeptical hunters.

It's not only Mitch Rompola's character here on the line. What about the character of those who say it's real??? You're going to have to perform character assassination on them too for us to believe they are all lying, and the guy with a grudge, and NO EVIDENCE is right with his speculation and allegations.
 
Im from Michigan and Mitch was a local ledgend way before this buck was shot, S/S. He killed two archery bucks before this buck that were the michigan state records, he basically beat his own record with the second buck. He had alot of isues with B&C and CBofM way before this buck was shot, and wouldnt have entered it into any record books anyways. Like I said earlier alotof the terms we use for mature bucks and their behaviors were started by him after Michigan writers interveiwed him and wrote his tactics. Myles Keller has stated that he used alot of Mitches tactics after reading them. So this deer I havent held in my hands, I dont know Mitch but have been reading about him all my life. I was not surprized when his picture came out on the internet with that buck. Also one thing that most folks dont talk about, this is the first world record rumor buck to have been shot where everyone had a computer and internet in their house so rumors flew like over night by anyone that had the internet. This guy couldnt take the fact that so many people were writing so much crap about him, and just stopped talking, making it even more questionable to some folks. Now a days if you shoot a buck thats world class you know what to expect if you let it go out on the web. We all know our local guy that kills big bucks every year that everyone starts rumors about, the real good ones not the 2 1/2 yr olds the guy that kills BIG bucks every year. Some guys cant just say wow hes better then me. They have to lie, or start rumors. This buck was killed on public land by the way!
 
81 - 99 of 99 Posts