New Jersey Hunters banner
1 - 20 of 24 Posts

Trout

· Registered
Joined
·
343 Posts
Discussion starter · #1 ·
A bead of sweat dripped off my nose as the black flies danced around my head like an old Indian war party before the attack. It was ungodly hot out for 6am but the draw of the current held me steadfast, focusing completely on my next target. The stream was churning aggressively around a gauntlet of rocks in front me. I pried small brown after small brown from each likely looking spot.



With a small flick of the wrist I sent my presentation on its way. I wasn’t happy with the distance or location of the cast so I manipulated it mid-air about a foot forward and a few inches to the left. The spinner crashed down right behind the boulder and I instinctively cranked the bail over on my Shimano Ci4. In an instant the water exploded and for the first time in 24+ years of spinner fishing I thought I was going to lose the grip of my custom building 5’1” rod I fondly refer to as ‘The Green Machine’. My pointer finger wrapped around the leg of the reel as the rod itself lost all of its bend and pointed straight at the fish. It was my last ditch effort to save my setup. I quickly regained my grip and the battle was on. I immediately saw that it wasn’t the largest fish on earth but the ferocity with which it hit simply took my breath away. When I finally landed the 18.5” wild brown I mumbled a little ‘nice job’ to it as I shook the hook loose and released it back to the water safe and sound. The single greatest ‘hit’ I’ve ever felt in trout fishing won’t soon be forgotten!



I took another moment to whip my brow again and swat at some black flies. Time wasn’t on my side so I needed to keep moving at a brisk pace. I didn’t really know it yet but the morning was going to be filled with all sorts of surprised. For the next 30 minutes browns and rainbows occupied my time and the sound of the rushing water filled my ears.







I approach the next large pool and let’er fly. Again, like wild browns often do, the spinner was hammered before I could even turn the bail over. The behemoth brown came to the surface and I couldn’t believe my eyes. It was a true giant in the 25-27” class that I had on my line. It was the fish that dreams are made of. The thoughts of personal glory danced through my head. I was on cloud nine……that was, until it opened its mouth and out popped the 7” wild brown that had actually taken my spinner on the drop!! I reeled the small trout in that was no worse for the wear. It didn’t even have a mark on it to be honest. I felt bad for the little guy because not only did it just get complete accosted by one of the largest browns I’d ever seen, but it also was probably the most disappointing trout I’ve ever caught in my life haha.
Yes it was disappointing to not land that fish but there was no time to hang my head. More good water lay ahead.
A few pools later my mind was reset when this angry 17” brown laid into my retrieve



And only a run or two later another slightly larger brown wanted to take my spinner home with it……but I wouldn’t allow it!!!



I was nearing the end of the short stretch that I intended to fish before work when the infamous ‘I May Never Know’ pool came into site. For years I’d fished this lunker of a looking spot and over and over I’ve came up empty. I always catch trout but nothing to gawk at. In June of 2013 I sent a cast into the narrow shoot to the left of the boulder and was rewarded with a triumphant strike which promptly snapped my line. For years I could only imagine the fish that embarrassed me so badly.



As I approached the correct casting angle I was ‘on edge’ just like I am every time I fish this spot. I know there’s a giant in there but when was I ever going to see it. Well, today was that day….FINALLY! When that spinner hit the water is just stopped dead. I couldn’t do a darn thing with the fish except just hang on tight! The monster rolled up and down the pool in a frantic attempt to shake free but the hook set was solid and my intent was on point. 12 years of fishing the spot was coming to a head and I was catching that fish no matter what. After about 45 seconds I slid the king of the hole into my grasp and took the pic I’d been waiting on for a loooong time.



At just over 22” he was a touch smaller than Monday’s trout but definitely heavier. The fish wasn’t going hungry in there that’s for sure! As I slid him back into the murky depth I gave a quick point up into the heavens and a little fist pump. I couldn’t choose any better spot to jump out and hit the road then right there!
 
Discussion starter · #2 ·
The next morning found me right where I left off for an even shorter trip. I had an 8am meeting so calling in late wasn’t an option but neither was missing a chance to fish optimum water levels and chase big fish, plus who could pass up this kind of heat and humidity. I was also concerned that the Black Flies missed me after spending plenty of time with me the day before.



And as luck would have it the early wakeup paid off just 15 minutes into the trip when this 19.5” wild brown grab hold for the long haul. After a few heroic leaps he gave up the goods for the hero shot!



I handled and released plenty of additonal browns for the next hour before it was time to shove off again and head to the office.
 
Discussion starter · #3 ·
Today found me on a different stream with the same intent. Find water, find fish, and hopefully catch a big one. Much like the past two day I found water conditions very much to my liking.



And while it wasn’t the fast and furious action we all love in May and June, this is mid-July, the dog days of summer, so fast and furious trout fishing is tough to find. I plodded along content in knee deep cold water picking my way to a nifty 13 trout per hour day. This was waaay more than enough to keep me busy



I could tolerate much slower fishing than that when conditions are right.





Hours passed yet still no noteworthy trout had ‘taken the bait’. I looked at my click counter and noted 71 trout taken with a good chunk of real estate ahead of me yet.
As I got closer to my bike that was stashed stealthily in the weeds somewhere upstream I pried additonal trout from most likely looking places. The sun finally peaked out for the first time in the day which didn’t help my cause but I pushed on. I turned the final corner of my trek and sent a rather mindless cast into the most innocent of spots when out of know where a large brown engulfed my spinner. It was just my week! This fish was different from the other. It barely fought at all. Just gave it up…..until the second I touched it. At that point it blew the surface of the water up and tore down stream. It was a pretty odd moment to be honest. I eventually caught up and got that cherished photo! Another 19”er in the books!



A few runs and a couple of trout later and I crested the bank to find my trusty bike safe and sound. A welcome site after such a long distance traveled. During the peddle back to the truck I relived the 6 large browns I’d taken over the past few days. You can’t force big trout moments, you can only hope for them, so when they stack up like that it creates a memory that will last a lifetime. Dang I love this sport!
 
Ok, I can't take it anymore! Don't take this the wrong way(although it may be hard not to), and I think I questioned you in the past, but please humor me if possible.

You're catching the fish no doubt, can't take that away from you. You're out there getting it done, you write a great story, and someone takes great pics of your catches. But being the "Jersey guy" that I am, I am naturally skeptical (yes, it's a character flaw many of us develop at birth), and I just can't fathom that there are that many areas, with that many trout, of that size, that nobody else is ever fishing, and when you get out there you can just hammer away at them.

Just feels like part of the story is missing...
 
Discussion starter · #15 ·
Not a problem in the slightest Pathman. I never have an issue with guys politely questioning what I do.....or impolitely questioning haha. To answer your question you are making a few assumptions in your post. I haven't stated that all of my fishing is done in Jersey. I've stated the opposite though. I live right on the border of New Jersey and PA. I fish both regularly and in fact fish PA more just cause there is far more opportunities. I also fish Maryland, NY and WV when that is the place to be. I have no trouble waking up at 2am to drive 3-4 hours, fish for 6-7 hours, and then drive home that afternoon. I go through great pains to place myself in the very best position to have a successful outing. I don't reflect where I'm fishing just cause I don't feel it's important to the story I write. I also like to keep friendly competition guessing ;-). Hope that that answers your question and explains things. I could be in Jersey one day and 300 miles away the next. It's all part of the fun for me!
 
Appreciate your response. It appears the missing ingredient is the lengths you go to find water that may hold fish of that caliber.
Just like the guys who locate and aquire the prime deer properties, they too appear to have some mystical powers, but in the end, you can't catch'em (or kill'em) if they're not there!

So, as always, location is the key, with your ability to actually catch them a close second I'm sure.

But, I still think there's some magic in that little gold bead spinner of yours...!
 
Appreciate your response. It appears the missing ingredient is the lengths you go to find water that may hold fish of that caliber.
Just like the guys who locate and aquire the prime deer properties, they too appear to have some mystical powers, but in the end, you can't catch'em (or kill'em) if they're not there!

So, as always, location is the key, with your ability to actually catch them a close second I'm sure.

But, I still think there's some magic in that little gold bead spinner of yours...!
There is no mystery here other than if the water is public or private. You need to notice small nuances in the pictures to give you a clue as to where he is fishing if that is what you aiming for. Very few streams/rivers are bank full of water this time of year, most have rocks protruding out of the water. Also, the mist/fog coming off the water should give you another clue as to the temp of the water considering trout like cold water. Everyone wants the info on where the big trout and big bucks are without doing the work of finding those areas themselves. I fish a steam in PA that I catch wild browns and brookies on flies every time I go no matter the time of year, some browns as large as 19inches. This stream has not been stocked since 2001 but i spent time unlocking its secrets, but it is better than any stream i have fished in NJ and is only 15-20 miles west of the NJ border. I never see anyone else there when I fish but the fish are there.
 
Discussion starter · #19 ·
For record.......I fish ONLY water open to public fishing. Ive never once in my life fished a stream that wasn't open to any other angler willing to drive to it. If I should ever fish a private section of stream, which I have very little interest in ever doing, It would be in the first sentence of anything I post. Integrity is very important to me.
 
I hear that Trout.

Strat, my intention was not to locate his spots, my question/skepticism was always in regards to that number and caliber of fish being caught in NJ when not one other fisherman was ever seen in any of his pics, simply not possible!
Which is obviously the case after hearing the lengths and distance he travels for that quality of fishing.
I'm sure there's an off beat stretch or two with a few good fish in NJ, but no way is anyone catching the numbers and size that Trout is catching.
BTW, 15-20 miles from NJ border may as well be Montana for most NJ trout fisherman!
 
1 - 20 of 24 Posts