New Jersey Hunters banner
1 - 20 of 21 Posts
I vote yes.

I've only been able to get out and glass on a few occasions and I have zero trail cameras running this year, as opposed to years past where I glass almost nightly and had 10+ cameras going, all year.

So far, I have not ever had a year that compares to this one. I'm literally in awe. It's bittersweet, because I wont be able to hunt but a few days, if I'm lucky, but the fact remains the same, more and MUCH biger bucks walking the fields this season !![up]
 
Must be me while I admit to seeing a few more deer this year than in say the past 3 years in my area I can't say I'm seeing more mature bucks in fact if you call a mature buck one thats 4.5 y.o. than I have seen none so far and perhaps 1 to 3 3.5 y.o. bucks and an handfull of 2.5 IMO most guys don't know what they are looking at and at times that statment includes me as most of us think any buck with a few points is older than he is.
 
Yes more bucks period! 4.5 plus are few and far between but way more than last season.
 
Must be me while I admit to seeing a few more deer this year than in say the past 3 years in my area I can't say I'm seeing more mature bucks in fact if you call a mature buck one thats 4.5 y.o. than I have seen none so far and perhaps 1 to 3 3.5 y.o. bucks and an handfull of 2.5 IMO most guys don't know what they are looking at and at times that statment includes me as most of us think any buck with a few points is older than he is.
Ya know what, I'm going to have to agree with this.

While its a fact that I've seen way more heavy racked bucks this year than before, I have no idea how old they are. I just assume they are older because they are sporting big time head gear.

I judge age as best as I can, but seeing nicely racked bucks and having the dynamics of the herd differ in the form of more mature deer, from years past, is entirely different and likely often misjudged.

Good point, Jakes !
 
Yes, but seeing more in general also.
 
I'm with the guys that say no.

I have seen what I can guess/assume to be 1.5-3.5 year old bucks with much better headgear than they would typicaly have, but not a greater number of mature bucks.

I'm with Jakesbeard, I don't think I've seen anything 4.5 years old or older, but I have seen three bucks that will score around 120, two that should make 125 and one that should be about 135.

They are all probably 2.5-3.5 years old.

I attribute the larger antlers on younger bucks this season to the following:

-Great acorn crop last year, so they were more healthy going into winter.

-Relatively mild winter, so they went into Spring healthier. (In the North anyway, I think the South got hammered, right?)

-VERY EARLY Spring greenup with a good amount of food available early on. This was one of the earliest green ups I've ever seen.


Everything seems to be happening a little earlier than usual too. Last night, I saw the first two bucks in full "hard horn"....So some have already shed the velvet. I had seen one two weeks ago with a bloody side, but I think he was injured, he also had a messed up leg.

But last night these were completely free of velvet, one was still bloody and wet looking, the other had probably shed a day or so ago because he was dried out and lighter colored. Of course there were still about 20+ other bucks that we saw still in velvet....
 
My customers have been seeing some monsters so far, 190, 170, 150 and lots of 140s These are reliable sources.
 
I'm with Jakesbeard,
Now ya done it,from here on in this is going to count against you with this crowd.
 
Now ya done it,from here on in this is going to count against you with this crowd.
I'm not overly concerned about that. [rofl] I'd rather be right than popular.:D

Our viewpoints may be unpopular at times, but I go by what I've experienced, witnessed and learned first hand over 20 years in the sport. I also keep in mind, years experience doesn't mean a whole lot if you don't take it seriously, really observe, and keep an open mind to learning at all times. But there are guys like you, with more serious years under the belt, and I'm always willing to listen and keep an open mind when they speak.

Unfortunately there's no shortage of "book learned" and "tv taught" pro-staffers and experts on hunting forums eager to ram their "knowledge" down your throat either.

Gotta be able to separate the wheat from the chaff, if you know what I mean!;)
 
way more mature bucks,(cause i havent shot any) just cant get them in range. havent scouted all my spots yet. last year i let 5 solid 3.5, 120-140s go. 1 was shot, they other 4 were still alive winter bow. saw 2 shooters on cams at a different spot.. should be a good year(what a jinx)
 
1 - 20 of 21 Posts