New Jersey Hunters banner
1 - 20 of 20 Posts

·
Registered
Joined
·
943 Posts
Discussion Starter · #1 ·
The Atlantic States Marine Fisheries Commission (ASMFC) will hold its winter meetings the first week in February. And that can mean only one thing: we're getting closer to learning what our 2012 fluke regulations might look like here in the Garden State.

While thanks to some controversial decision making on the part of federal officials, we have to take a quota hit this year, our actual allowable harvest will increase because anglers in our state did not hit their quota last season.

When the ASMFC meets, it will consider a slew of potential regulatory options proposed by the New Jersey Division of Fish and Wildlife which will meet the federal harvest limits. The ASMFC will whittle those options down, and send several back to the state Marine Fisheries Council, which will choose one at a meeting in the spring.

New Jersey is allocated a recreational target of 1,090,407 fish for 2012, according to documentation filed with the ASMFC, a liberalization to the tune of 38 percent over the 2011 season.

Though it's based on pure sampling data using a number of methodologies, there is a chance that New Jersey anglers could see a summer flounder season where they're able to take home a fish smaller than 18-inches for the first time since 2007.

The 18-inch minimum size limit has been highly controversial, mainly because biologists have found that virtually all fish that reach 18 inches or larger are females.

For 2012, options include a May 5 to Sept. 23 season with 17.5 inch size limit. They also include seasons ranging from April 29 through Sept. 23 and May 5 through Sept. 29 with a 17.5 inch size limit. All of these options include an four fish bag limit, however, down from eight fish in 2011.

The options that keep the size limit at 18 inches all keep the bag limit at eight fish per day through a 170 day season, with date options including April 28 through Oct. 14; April 7 through Sept. 23; and May 5 through Oct 21.

In my opinion columns over the years, I have long advocated for a shorter size limit rather than extending the season length (or upping the bag limit, which next-to-nobody can achieve anyway).

For the majority of anglers, a shorter size limit will always equal more of an impetus to go out on the water, patronize bait shops, marinas and party boats, and increase one's chances of taking a fish home for dinner.

Participation in the 2011 fluke fishery, despite a longer season, was terrible from an anecdotal standpoint – and this is coming from someone who's out on the water nearly every day. September was – as it often is – a washout. Back bay and shore-based anglers, as usual, take the brunt of high size limits.

There is no doubt that for-hire boat operators will rally in favor of a longer season at all costs (I do understand why), but for independent anglers (and the businesses they support), it will always be my belief that a shorter size limit equals greater participation and a well-rounded distribution of access to the fishery whether one goes out on party boats, operates his or her own boat (in the ocean or bay), or fishes from shore.

For all the technical stuff, check out the filings of the ASMFC's summer flounder committee.

About this column: An update on local fishing, reeled in every Friday on Patch!

Capt Bob Morrell
Sandy Hook Fishing Adventures
www.sandyhookfishing.com
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,588 Posts
My opinion:
2 fish at 16 inches, rest of bag limit 18 inches

Then a guy who is going to drive an hour or more to hop on a party boat is at least going to get a dinner for him and his wife out of it.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,274 Posts
me too chris... just incase you gut hook one also i spear fish so if i make a mistake..(i never do,i only shoot 20" but new guys do,shit looks biggers underwater)
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,797 Posts
How about 16" fish period ..commercial size isn't going to be changed.....but remember recs..do all the damage to the fish stocks
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,261 Posts
I think they have to keep in mind the captains, etc of the recreational fishing boats. If you increase the likely hood you'll be going home with keepers, you increase the customers on the party boats, etc..
At the same time, I dont think there should be a free for all on the fluke.. Guess there needs to be a balance.
Maybe 4 16" or better, 4 18" or better?
than it gets confusing to some, like a lot of NJ's other regulations...
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
9,711 Posts
6 fish at 16 " plenty of fillets for few meals while not being greedy with a high bag limit.

They already have a mortality rate built in for everything we throw back under 18 so why not allow those fish to just be kept
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
120 Posts
If a 18" or over fluke is a female then better management bag limit would be say 1 fish over 18" and 6 fish slot limit at 16"-18". better eating fish also plus letting the big females swim,the bigger the fish the more eggs they release.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
2,708 Posts
keep it at 8 fish , 4- 18" and 4- 17", at 18 inch regs, you always seem to pull up a number of fish that just make it , but dont wanna throw in the box cause you are affraid the state game officers will come fine you for them....18 inch fish give a nice fillet and 17 inch fish are still a decent fillet , a family of 4-6 can eat a really healthy and great meal from this bag size and limit !!!
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
907 Posts
I'm really thinking outside the box. I'm thinking no closed season. What ever regs work best from around momorial day to around labor day. then after that 3 fish at 20 inches. I'm just saying I would like to have the oppertunity to fluke fish into the fall.
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,588 Posts
If a 18" or over fluke is a female then better management bag limit would be say 1 fish over 18" and 6 fish slot limit at 16"-18". better eating fish also plus letting the big females swim,the bigger the fish the more eggs they release.
[up] maybe 2 fish over 18"
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
850 Posts
Would love to see something change where the amount of fish going home could increase. I would like to see 2 over 18" and 4 at 16-17" something along those lines. I generally spend a lot of time out on the water and usually 4 or so on the boat at time. if we kept 6 fish the whole last season it was a lot. Caught tons in the 16-17 range. It gets costly and frustrating for the private boat owner who can easily put thousands of dollars into the economy and not keep a stinking fish. [wallmad]
 

·
Registered
Joined
·
1,588 Posts
It gets costly and frustrating for the private boat owner
I think it's most frustrating for the guys in the bays and rivers without a large enough boat to run outside where a lot of the doormats are. I bet I caught 1000 16 in fluke in the bay the last two summers.
 
1 - 20 of 20 Posts
Top