Chris I agree with you I think it could be the same deer. If it's not he's from the same gene line and most likely you would have gotten pics of both him and a larger version if that was the case. Some guys are saying get him out of the herd but I dont see anything necessarily bad genetic wise about this deer and he is still quite young. I'd give him some time Chris. You know your deer and let the cameras do the work. If that's not the same buck then it's a twin which I have seen before. In hopewell I was watching twin ten points one season. Their racks were so identical you couldn't tell them apart or know it was a different deer unless both were standing next to each other proving it was two different deer.